Isner Insurance Associates, Inc — Commercial insurance brokers photo 1 of 5

Photo 1 of 5

Commercial insurance brokers

Isner Insurance Associates, Inc

★ 4.9 (127 reviews) ·
3695 N High St, Columbus, OH 43214

Highlights from 127 Google reviews

Sourced from Google.
Google reviewer
Dec 17, 2025

Outstanding insurance provider with exceptional customer service We use Isner Insurance Associates, Inc. for both our business insurance and home insurance, and they have been amazing to work with. Anytime we need a COI, it’s completed within minutes. Most recently, Sam Isner helped me, and I kid you not—it took him about 5 minutes to get everything over to me. That level of responsiveness is hard to find. I’ve worked with Tom Isner in the past, and even when different team members assist us, the customer service never disappoints. Everyone is professional, knowledgeable, and easy to work with. They are straightforward and always willing to help you find the best insurance options. We’ve had a great experience with both our home and business coverage and highly recommend them.

Google reviewer
Nov 28, 2025

We’ve been working with this insurance company for a little over 10 years now for all of our commercial policies, and they’ve honestly been great. Sam Jr. has helped us through so many renewals and changes, and he always makes everything simple and stress-free. Their customer service has always been solid, and anytime we’ve needed something, they’ve been quick and easy to work with. Definitely appreciate them and highly recommend.

Google reviewer
Jun 18, 2026

My husband and I switched to Isner from several other insurance agents who weren't cutting it. We have a home, rental property, and 2 cars, and Isner was able to initially save us a lot of money, while keeping appropriate coverage. Even years later, our insurance costs have remained pretty consistent despite inflation. Highly recommend!

Google reviewer
Aug 26, 2026

If you are in need of a new Insurance Agent I can tell you Isner Insurance is top-notch. Sam is so thorough and will go through all your current policies to get you the best deal. He is friendly, kind, and always responds quickly whenever you need anything. I would highly recommend him to anyone.

Google reviewer
May 13, 2026

Sam and I shared mutual client and did an incredible job taking care of them for their homeowners insurance! They are super happy and very much appreciated the referral. I will continue to refer my clients over and over again to Sam and his team at Isner Insurance for my clients in and around Central Ohio.

Google reviewer
Dec 16, 2025

Great experience with the Isners. They helped me secure Commercial Insurance, General Liability, Auto, and Umbrella coverage quickly and efficiently. The team was knowledgeable, responsive, and made sure my business was properly protected. Highly recommend Isner for business insurance needs!

Contact us

Questions about the guide? Reach out.

Ask about getting your firm listed, advertising, or anything you see in the guide. A real person on our team will reply by email.

Powered bygreetform

We only use this to reply to you. We never share it.