Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group — Independent insurance agencies photo 1 of 4

Photo 1 of 4

Independent insurance agencies

Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group

★ 5.0 (1,356 reviews) ·
7212 Shadeland Ave #201, Indianapolis, IN 46250

Highlights from 1,356 Google reviews

Sourced from Google.
Google reviewer
Aug 22, 2026

Dear Scott, I am writing to express my sincere appreciation for the outstanding service you and your team provide. For over ten years, Wenclewicz Insurance has consistently delivered a boutique approach, ensuring I have the best possible policies for my business, auto, and home insurance needs. Whenever an insurance situation arises, your office handles it seamlessly. I have worked closely with Shawanna, Doug, and Kelly, and they have always resolved my requests the same day while keeping me fully informed. Choosing your team to represent and protect my interests remains the best decision I could have made. You will always have my business. Best regards, Ryan Lipps

Google reviewer
Aug 15, 2026

I can’t say enough good things about Scott Wenclewicz and his entire team. They are incredibly knowledgeable, responsive, and genuinely invested in doing what’s best for their clients. What I appreciate most about the Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group is how thorough their process is. Each year, they take the time to walk through our coverage, review the details, explain our options, and make sure we understand exactly what we’re getting and why. It’s clear that they don’t just view insurance as a transaction—they take a long-term, consultative approach to helping their clients make good decisions. They make the entire process easy, organized, and reassuring. I highly recommend the Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group to anyone looking for an insurance team they can truly trust.

Google reviewer
Aug 11, 2026

Gabe Leffler at Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group was fantastic to work with for both my home and auto insurance. He took the time to really listen to what I wanted and needed from my coverage, answered all of my questions, and was incredibly patient throughout the process. I especially appreciated that Gabe took the time to run multiple quotes and options rather than just giving me one choice. Once I made my decision, he coordinated everything, including providing the necessary proof of insurance to my new mortgage lender, which made the whole process incredibly easy on my end. I was comparing three different insurance agencies offering fairly similar options, and Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group was by far the standout when it came to customer service. Gabe was responsive, thorough, and genuinely helpful from start to finish. I highly recommend him!

Google reviewer
Aug 10, 2026

My dependable Insurance agent retired two years ago. I wanted to find a person to person agent who heard my needs. When I didn’t find that at the old company, I looked around and this Wenclewicz group was referred to me from a friend. After meeting with Doug, and having him figure out the best plan for my home and car, I decided to go with Wenclewicz. An independent agent makes sense for me. Being able to sit and discuss the variables, works for me. The rates were very competitive without losing the quality, and in one case, improves it. All in, he saved me a significant amount of premium cost. I am most happy with my new Insurance agent. Thank you, Doug and team!!

Google reviewer
Aug 5, 2026

Writing ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Justin was outstanding to work with! He helped me find a new homeowners insurance policy with the best coverage at a great price. He took the time to shop around and find the best deal for my situation, and his sense of urgency really stood out throughout the entire process. Justin was easy to talk to, responsive, and genuinely cared about helping me. He answered all of my questions promptly and kept me informed every step of the way. It's rare to find someone who is both knowledgeable and truly invested in their clients. I highly recommend Justin to anyone looking for an insurance agent who goes above and beyond!

Google reviewer
Jul 3, 2026

⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ I had a fantastic experience with Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group. Brian was incredibly helpful, knowledgeable, and made the entire process of bundling my home and auto insurance simple and stress free. He took the time to explain all of my options, answered every question I had, and found me great coverage at a competitive price. Customer service like this is hard to find. Brian was professional, responsive, and genuinely cared about making sure I got the best policy for my needs. I highly recommend Scott Wenclewicz Insurance Group to anyone looking for home or auto insurance. Thank you, Brian, for making the process so easy!

Contact us

Questions about the guide? Reach out.

Ask about getting your firm listed, advertising, or anything you see in the guide. A real person on our team will reply by email.

Powered bygreetform

We only use this to reply to you. We never share it.